Old Captiva House

Once a one-room schoolhouse of Captiva’s pioneer settlers, Old Captiva House is today a TripAdvisor top-rated restaurant with a charming, casual, Gulf-front setting that features an award-winning menu beloved by guests and locals of Sanibel and Captiva Islands. Whether it’s a bright morning breakfast served outdoors among the flowers or indoors — or an extensive, creative dinner menu of mouth-watering island favorites that focus on fresh Gulf of Mexico seafood, plus the island’s exclusive sushi menu, all served with an extensive collection of fine wines, specialty drinks and coffees — you’re sure to be delighted by the amazing talents of our long-time islands favorite Executive Chef.

Visit Website
Make a Reservation

Crow’s Nest Steakhouse

Welcome to Crow’s Nest Steakhouse where, deliciously and beautifully, you can expand your horizons. Crow’s Nest Steakhouse stands tall above the acclaimed Shipyard Restaurant at ‘Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa of Captiva. Crow’s Nest Steakhouse is the only second-level dining destination on Captiva or Sanibel with a glorious beachfront view of the Gulf of Mexico and its amazing sunsets.

Visit Website
Reserve a Table

The Shipyard

Throughout the past century of Captiva Island’s heritage, vessels of all sizes have sailed and moored here — for leisure, for sport, for exploration, and once upon a time, for the clandestine transport of whiskey and illicit goods.

Amid the captivating tapestry of our island’s nautical history, we christen The Shipyard restaurant — a tribute to the bygone days of Florida’s fishing and boating legacy, beckoning to the cherished past and the promising future, offering delightful experiences and exquisite feasts to all who venture in. 

Visit Website
No Reservations Required

Captiva Crust

Captiva Crust is a delightful addition to the culinary scene on Captiva Island, offering a unique and personalized pizza experience that has captured the hearts and taste buds of locals and tourists alike. Nestled between the island’s scenic beauty and ‘Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa, this charming little pizzeria exudes a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. What sets Captiva Crust apart is its commitment to customization, allowing customers to craft their own perfect personal pizzas from a diverse array of fresh and high-quality toppings, sauces, and cheeses.

Visit Website